If you have a sign and wish for me to pick it up, please let me know either by sending an email to IndianSpringsGuy@sbcglobal.net or calling 281-292-2925.
Showing posts with label Government Transparency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government Transparency. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

I am most proud of lowering taxes to 32.8 cents

The incumbent in position 4 is Ed Robb. Are you as dumbfounded as I am on his claims to have lowered taxes to 32.8 cents per $100?   There is a huge problem in this claim, as I see it. It cannot be related to the return on sales taxes, but must be related to his specific accomplishments. Let's see if we can find them.

On Aug 29th, 2007, in a presentation on the feasibility of annexing The Woodlands into the TCID tax district, a forecast of 29.7 cents was presented to the residents of The Woodlands. This became the expectation behind the ad valorem proposition for the expanded tax district, to be called The Woodlands Township. Voters went to the polls with that tax rate expectation. Some say there was an assumption that the reserves collected by WCA would be transferred to the Township and instead, the WCA gave it back to the residents before formation of the Township and thus the higher tax rate. Even if this is the truth, it still makes no difference to the accomplishment claim of Dr Robb. He should be held accountable for the mistake, since he was on the board of TCID and adopted this rate based on sound analysis. Generally the incumbents have not yet all faced up to the fact that they are held accountable for mistakes as well as bad decisions. 

Now let's take a look at how our current tax rate came to be. Budget workshops of the directors had been conducted to determine the proposed budget for consideration before the final budget meeting. Going into the last budget meeting, there were several pending issues including financial reserves and what could be removed from the budget.

The final budget meeting was conducted just last year as part of  the Township Board meeting of August 26th 2009 when our tax rate was also established.  To establish a tax rate,  the Township Directors first had to set the budget.  The proposed 2010 budget was presented and a motion to adopt it opened up discussion. An amendment was made to raise spending on outside (Shenandoah and Oak Ridge) police enforcement in The Woodlands by $92,000, but no vote was required. That became part of a previously approved amendment. Then a motion for funding the Indian Springs Fire Station was discussed and approved.  

An amendment motion was put on the floor to remove certain items from the budget to enable a lower tax rate. Dr Robb voted against that, choosing to join the same group he always seems to vote with, against a lowered budget. As a result, the budget was approved with the additional funding of the outside police contracts. That satisfied the requirements for funding the budget through taxation.

The stage was set for a motion and discussion on the tax rate. A motion for a 32-cent rate was put on the floor for discussion.  Dr Robb voted against this motion  that failed. Next, a motion for 32.8 cents was put on the floor. Director Sutton (Development Co) amended the motion to be 33.8 cents, because the Tax Assessor recommended 33.5 cents. Dr Robb voted for this higher tax rate. That also failed. Then Directors Richmond and Tough were the swing votes, not Dr Robb, to establish the lower tax rate of 32.8 cents. If other budget items would have been cut, the tax rate probably would have been even lower.  

Now I compare this to the article in The Villager where Dr Robb says -

" During my service on The Woodlands Township Board, I’ve worked for real results for residents. Some of the results I’m most proud of include:
1. ...
2. ...
3. ... 
4. Lowering property taxes to 32.8 cents per $100 valuation"

If he was responsible for lowering taxes, why did others have to vote against him to lower the tax rate?

Now I suppose you know where I stand on excessive budgeting, spending and taxing! In a corporate environment, we would have assumed there was fluff in the budget. Departments tend to add fluff and hide it in specific projects. When you come from a background that does not emphasize fiscal responsibility to stockholders, then there is excess budgeting and waste. From what is visible to us, the stockholders, we have budget excess, and therefore we have higher taxes than required, but Dr Robb is not the person pushing those buttons, at least not from anything visible. If invisible ... well, we would have an even bigger problem.

Saturday, April 24, 2010

Voting history on key issues

Courtesy of Adrian Heath.





Attendance Record
Campbell
Mathews
Hunter
Robb
Attendance at Board Meetings
100%
95%
100%
68%
Attendance at April 19 League of Women’s Voters Forum  Attendance at April 16 Woodlands Chamber of Commerce and Hispanic Chamber Candidate Presentations
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
 Yes
Absent
Absent

Voting Record
Campbell
Mathews
Hunter
Robb
Did you support the request by Director Hausman to have two meetings per month of the Board, one in the morning and one in the evening so more residents could attend such meetings?
Yes
No
Yes
Absent
Did you support setting the new property tax rate at 32.8 cents?
No
Yes
No
Yes
Did you support the proposed 2010 budget amendment to reduce Township spending?
Yes
No
Yes
No
Did you support developing site plans for a new ice rink?
No
Yes
Yes
Absent
Did you support donating $250,000 to the Cynthia Woods Mitchell Pavilion in return for an option to use land for three months out of the year for the construction of an ice rink?
No
Yes
No
Yes
Did you support posting the voting record of the Township Board on the Township web site?
Yes
No
Yes
Absent
Did you support amending the 2010 Parks Budget to allocate surplus funds to Town Center projects rather than allowing such funds to be used to build up needed operating and capital reserves?
No
Yes
no
Absent
Did you vote in favor of the Water Taxis Bail-Out?
No
Yes
No
Absent
Did you support deferring the Water Taxi decision until after the Town Hall Meeting in order to get input from residents?
Yes
No
Yes
Absent
Did you support extending the law enforcement agreements with the City of Shenandoah, the City of Oak Ridge North and the Alpha and Omega Mounted Patrol in lieu of putting such money into additional Sherriff patrols?
Yes
Yes
Yes
Absent
Did you support selecting DSC members through an appointed Committee composed of elected WCA Board members instead of having the Committee on Governance and Nominations bring forth recommendations?
Yes
No
Yes
No
In light of new duties being transferred to the DSC, have you supported changing the composition of the DSC to include TWA property owners as well as WCA property owners?
Yes
No
Yes
No



I'd like to add that the attendance numbers are incorrect on this chart. I recalculated the number for Ed Robb and the result was 37% absenteeism.

Friday, April 23, 2010

Township Advisory Meetings

I established a position a few weeks ago that the Policing Advisory Committee should be open. Folks who do volunteer work for the Township and villages, generally do not like Texas open meetings, because nothing off the agenda can take place at the meeting. The idea here is to open the meetings to the residents and allow a wider level of participation. The public needs to be able to listen, speak and be heard. They need to know. It is important for many reasons. I am hearing other candidates begin to speak out also now. An open government is essential for public confidence and ultimately budget control. The Open Meetings Act is designed to give the public more control over the outcome.  This particular subject is even more important than the other advisory committees in that respect. 

Although the current process was recommended by the Village Liaison Committee and endorsed by the Township Board, I believe the process falls way short on what is actually needed. Establishing a village representative to ensure all villages are represented and there is consistent attendance is important, but those representatives will not represent the public in general. Those elected to the villages are not diverse enough for this subject. They are typically entrenched in their own perspectives. Those people normally represent informed residents and those who have skills and confidence enough to run for a village office.

Those residents behind closed doors who are afraid to step out will step out to attend police advisory meetings! That is evident from the first Watch meeting.

Representation is not through villages. It is by personal involvement. Conduct these meetings openly with published agendas and give people an opportunity to speak. There is no need in my mind to confine the agenda, but perhaps it would better serve the public anyway. Make the minutes available to the public. This is no longer an association. It is a government that needs to be transparent in every way possible. This is possible!